The other valves look different and they have like a dip stick in them. Whet exactly is that??? Should I put oil in them.
Oh Man I just laughed so hard!
You have an old school Toro flo valve ( 6 months of not doing diagnosis , I can't remember if Hunter has a valve like this too, but i'm pretty sure it's the toro) , the 'dipstick ' is the bleed. If you loosened this bleed a little bit the valve will manually be turned on. However since you have a master valve it will not unless you had the master valve manually turned on, or turned on from controller.
Dont' worry about the wiring, or the wire color. You issue is a physical condition not an a electrical problem.
So your goal at this point is to find which valve is stuck on
I was going to suggest to use your zone guide if you had one ( Ie zone 4 South Side lawn which is where the 4 stuck heads are ) and feel the solenoid viberate but since you polled the wires from the controller I'm going to guess you didn't lable them. If you did and have a zone guide, do this.
If not
Go ahead and turn on your master valve from the controller and walk out to the 4 sprinkler heads that are on. Go to the NEAREST valve box and listen to these valves.. You should be hearing clear as day which valve it is that's stuck on. If not you can touch them and probably feel which one is viberating. If both of those don't work you can GENTLY turn the flow control down on each valve until the water stops. The flow control is the round portion on top of the valve
When you find your stuck valve.. I recommend to just replace the sucker.. But you may take it apart and see what is fauling up the valve